I went to the Gulf Education and Training Exhibition this morning. It's an enormous regional conference featuring schools and educational programs from all over the world. You wander through the pavilions, marveling: "Look, there are the French schools! Oh my, there sure are a lot of Canadian schools! My goodness, how will we
ever find time to visit all the
British schools?" And I didn't even go in the Asia and Middle East areas, which were huge.
But then your reverie fades, and you say, "Where are the American schools? I see Grambling State University, of Louisiana. A fine school. And there's Southeast Missouri State University, of Cape Girardeau. Good of them to show up. But where, in heaven's name, are the rest of the American schools?"
I absolutely
hate that we don't seem to be even
trying to compete for the world's talent. You could make the argument that if we're already the prime destination for the world's best students, we don't need to spend too much effort recruiting. But that's bullshit, for two reasons. First of all, I think I continue to see McDonald's advertising, even though we can be reasonably sure everyone knows about this hamburger establishment. Second, we're wrong to think that we're still the world's unquestioned first stop for education. Our population of foreign students has plummeted since 9/11, while the student populations of Canada, the UK, Europe, Australia and China are soaring.
This is how you lose the War on Terror in the long run.
Students who come to the U.S. fall in love with it; how could they not? Students who want to come here but find the door slammed in their faces harbor lifelong resentments. These are the kids who will grow up to become the ruling classes of their own countries. This is how reputations are won and lost in the world.
America's reputation in the world has certainly changed since 9/11. But from what I see here, it isn't primarily because of the war in Iraq. It's because we're snubbing this region. They want to love us and live in our country, but we give many of them the finger when they try.
I hear students talking about their desire to study in America, often followed by their regret that it no longer seems possible. I see students heading for Germany and Australia instead. These kids -- future opinion makers in the Middle East -- want to join our team. We should want them to. I'm pissed off for the same reason I was pissed off that we were the
only country without a pavilion at Dubai's Global Village. It sends a message loud and clear: We don't give a shit about you. These are the messages that speak louder than anything President Bush can say about how much we love freedom. I think Bush was right to want to bring democracy to Iraq and the rest of this area. Much as I don't care for him personally, I admire his instincts on this and he may one day be seen as visionary.
But from my little perch here in the liberal part of the Middle East, we're not making the right moves. Our country comes off as huge, attractive and uncaring. Sometimes even a little hostile. Anybody who's ever been snubbed by an attractive but arrogant person -- whether a member of the opposite sex or not -- knows how infuriating it can be, how belittling.
Almost every influential person you hear about in the Gulf region either lived in the U.S. as a student, or studied at the American School of Beirut. Back then, we welcomed them, and that's why we have friends in the Gulf today. We're not going to have these friends tomorrow, I think. Couldn't we make a showing here at these conferences? Would it be so much trouble? If a tiny little Missouri bootheel school can make it, we don't have any excuses. Goddammit, it just bothers me.
* Tomorrow: Back to silly jokes and pictures.
